Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 139

As usual, when I listen to General Conference, I try to identify teachings that help me deal with perfectionistic thinking. Here are three conference messages that stood out to me from earlier this month.

1. Elder Edward Dube — Come unto Christ

Elder Dube’s message is probably the most directly relevant talk in the entire conference for someone dealing with perfectionism. He addresses the mistaken idea that we must first make ourselves good enough before approaching the Savior.

“We do not need to perfect ourselves to come to Christ. We come to Christ to be perfected.”

Elder Dube explains that coming to Christ involves action, surrender, and a willing heart. We don’t have to fix everything ourselves before asking for His help.

Perfectionism often reverses the gospel’s order of operations. We tell ourselves:

– First, I must overcome this weakness; then I can feel close to God.

– First, I must become more disciplined; then I can feel good about myself.

– First, I must stop making mistakes; then I can trust that I am making spiritual progress.

Elder Dube points us in the opposite direction. We come to Christ with our weaknesses, not after we have eliminated them. His grace is part of the process of change, not a reward for completing it. This doesn’t mean that our choices don’t matter or that repentance isn’t necessary. It means that we don’t have to earn the right to seek the help that makes repentance and change possible. A question I might ask myself: Am I trying to overcome my weaknesses through my own willpower before I allow the Savior to help me?

2. Elder Hutch U. Fale — I Am a Child of God

Elder Fale teaches that understanding our Heavenly Father’s love and our identity as His children is essential for our happiness.

“I am a child of God and He loves me.”

He teaches that our Heavenly Father loved us before we were born, loves us today, and will love us tomorrow. That love can give us courage to do our best and humility to turn to Him when we need help.

Perfectionism often attaches our worth to our performance. We may feel valuable when we succeed, when we are obedient, and when we meet expectations. But when we fail, we begin questioning our identity.

Elder Fale invites us to ground our identity in our relationship with our Heavenly Father. We can take our shortcomings seriously without defining ourselves by them. And we can repent without concluding that we are bad people. I might ask myself: If I truly believed that Heavenly Father loved me on my worst day as well as my best day, how would I treat myself differently when I fall short?

3. Elder Michael A. Dunn — The Ninety and Ten

Elder Dunn uses an ultramarathon experience to illustrate how the Savior helps us endure burdens and keep moving forward, even when we’re tired and discouraged.

“The Redeemer rescues not by shortening our course but by helping us lengthen our stride.”

Sometimes perfectionists aren’t asking too much of themselves because they are lazy or unwilling to work. They’re already working really hard. Their difficulty is that they believe they must keep pushing hard regardless of exhaustion or personal limitations.

Elder Dunn’s message offers a different understanding of divine help. The Savior doesn’t always remove the challenge or make the journey shorter. He helps us carry it.

This can mean learning to accept our present limitations, asking for help, adjusting our expectations, and taking the next step without needing to feel strong first. For someone who is getting older, experiencing chronic illness, struggling with an addiction, or facing a hard season of life, this message is very meaningful. Faithfulness doesn’t mean we have to pretend that we have unlimited capacity. A question I might ask myself: Where am I trying to carry something alone that the Savior is inviting me to let Him help me carry?

These talks offer answers to some common perfectionistic thoughts.

Perfectionistic thought: “I have to get my life together before I can come to Christ.”

Healthier response: “I come to Christ so He can help change me.” — Elder Dube

Perfectionistic thought: “My mistakes mean I’m not good enough.”

Healthier response: “I am a beloved child of God, even while I am growing.” — Elder Fale

Perfectionistic thought: “I should be able to handle everything myself.”

Healthier response: “The Savior helps me carry burdens I cannot carry alone.” — Elder Dunn

For a person struggling with perfectionism, maybe the most important question is not, “How can I finally become good enough?” It is, “What would change if I trusted Jesus Christ enough to let Him help me right where I am?”

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 134

In Latter-day Saint culture, we talk a lot about becoming better. We covenant to improve, repent daily, serve more, love more, do more. That striving can be beautiful. It can also become heavy.

Over the years, both personally and in working with others, I’ve noticed two different struggles that often get confused, perfectionism and scrupulosity. They look similar on the surface. Both involve high standards. Both involve guilt. Both can make you feel like you’re never quite enough. But they are not the same problem, and they don’t heal in the same way. For Church members, understanding the difference can be helpful.

Initially, in comparing the two, you may expect me to show that one is good and the other it bad. Unfortunately, both have detrimental impacts, as you’ll soon discover.

Perfectionism is the relentless pressure to perform flawlessly. It says: If I make a mistake, I’ve failed. If I’m not progressing, I’m regressing. If people see my weaknesses, they won’t respect me. God must be disappointed in me.

Perfectionism is performance based. It focuses on outcomes, achievements, image, and comparison. In church life, it might sound like: I should be a better parent. I should read more scriptures. I should feel the Spirit more. Everyone else seems to have it together.

Perfectionism often produces anxiety, shame, and exhaustion. It turns discipleship into a treadmill you can’t step off. Ironically, perfectionists are often deeply sincere people who want to do what’s right. But instead of drawing closer to Christ, they feel perpetually at arms length from Him.

Scrupulosity is different. It’s not just about doing well. It’s about being morally or spiritually “safe.” It says: What if I sinned and didn’t realize it? What if I didn’t repent properly? What if my motives weren’t pure enough? What if God is upset with me right now?

Scrupulosity is fear-based. It’s driven by anxiety about sin, worthiness, and judgment from God. People with scrupulosity often confess the same things repeatedly, obsess over whether they took the sacrament worthily, fear they’ve committed some serious sin when they haven’t, or feel constant guilt even when doing their best.

While perfectionism says, “I must do everything right,” scrupulosity says, “I might be spiritually in danger even when nothing is wrong.” It can feel like living under a cloud that never lifts.

Both struggles distort how we experience the gospel. Perfectionism distorts grace. Scrupulosity distorts safety.

Perfectionism whispers: God loves the best version of you. Scrupulosity whispers: God might withdraw His love at any moment. Neither message comes from Christ.

Both perfectionism and scrupulosity are attempts to manage fear by controlling behavior. Perfectionism tries to control outcomes. Scrupulosity tries to control moral risk. Both hope that if we do everything right, we’ll finally feel peace. But peace doesn’t come from control. It comes from trust.

For perfectionism, healing involves learning that my worth doesn’t equal performance. For scrupulosity, healing involves learning that God is safe, and trusting that sincere repentance is sufficient. In both cases, the deeper cure is the same. A secure relationship with a merciful Savior. Jesus did not say, “Be perfect immediately, or I can’t help you.” He said: “Come unto Me. Walk with Me”

God isn’t looking for reasons to disqualify you. He’s looking for ways to rescue you. If you are sincerely trying, even imperfectly, you are already moving toward Him.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 130

I turned 70 this month. I won’t pretend that number didn’t give me pause. Birthdays like this tend to invite thoughts of years lived, mistakes made, blessings received, and questions still unanswered.

One thing has become clearer to me. If I want these later years to be peaceful and meaningful, I have to be careful not to turn my old perfectionism inward and let it rob me of joy. I don’t want to spend my time sitting in a rocking chair on the front porch, watching cars drive up and down the road, and yelling at the neighbor kids to stay off the lawn.  

For many of us in the Church, perfectionism doesn’t always look harsh or self-centered. Sometimes it comes out more subtly. It sounds like: I should be stronger than this by now. I should have more faith. I shouldn’t still be struggling with my body, my energy, or my emotions.

We know the scripture about becoming “perfect in Christ,” but somewhere along the way, some of us learned to interpret that as being hard on ourselves until we finally get it right.

Aging has a way of revealing how unkind that approach really is. Our bodies slow down. Energy comes and goes. Old regrets sometimes resurface. And if we’re not careful, we start treating these natural parts of aging as personal failures rather than normal parts of mortality.

One of the most freeing realizations I’ve had is this: aging is not a performance review. It’s not a test to see whether we exercised enough, served enough, or overcame everything we thought we should have overcome by now. Mortality doesn’t work that way. The gospel teaches us that growth is lifelong. And also, that weakness is not evidence that I’m a disappointment to God. “I give unto men weakness,” the Lord says, not as punishment, but as an invitation to humility and grace.

When we’re younger, much of life is about building careers, families, testimonies, and callings. Later life invites a different kind of discipleship. Less proving. More receiving. Receiving help. Receiving rest. Receiving the fact that slowing down doesn’t mean we’re sliding backward spiritually. I’ve noticed that people who seem to age with the most peace are not those who cling tightly to who they used to be, but those who allow themselves to become who they are now, without shame.

One of the quiet tasks of aging is learning to put down the internal checklist. The one that keeps track of 1) what I should still be able to do, 2) what others my age seem to be doing better, and 3) what I wish I had done differently.

For my birthday, my wife gave me a mug. On the outside, it says “Man of wisdom.” I hope that’s who I’m becoming. 

As I step into this new decade, my goal is not to age flawlessly or even impressively. My goal is to age faithfully. To trust that the Lord is far more interested in my heart than in my productivity.

If perfectionism once pushed me forward, I no longer want it driving the rest of the journey. There is a quieter strength available now, one rooted in humility, compassion, and trust in Christ.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 129

Last month, Elder Karl D. Hirst, General Authority Seventy, spoke at a BYU-Idaho Devotional. His talk was about repentance, which, for me, is linked to perfectionism. I’ve written about that connection in previous blog posts. 

For most of my life, I’ve had a pretty specific relationship with repentance. In my mind, it was mostly about clearing guilt, coming clean, and trying to avoid sinning in the future. But listening to this talk, I had a surprising realization. Repentance isn’t just about cleansing. It’s about changing into a better version of myself, even when I haven’t “messed up.” 

One of the most powerful ideas I heard is that imperfection and weakness are not proof of failure; they’re proof that we’re capable of growth. They’re part of the plan, not a distraction from it. Perfectionism often convinces me that flaws disqualify me. The gospel teaches that flaws prepare me. They make space for Christ’s grace.

Repentance literally means a change of heart and mind, a shift toward God, toward goodness, and toward better thinking and living. Nothing about that definition says repentance is only about sin. It’s about change. That means I can repent when I’m emotionally dysregulated, when I want more patience or optimism, and when I want deeper faith. I don’t need to wait for a big mistake to invite Christ into my life. His enabling power is accessed the same way as His cleansing power, through turning to Him. 

One of the most reassuring truths I heard was this: “Being weak does not mean we are Satan’s, it means we are capable of growth. Our weakness is God’s opportunity. Perfection will take care of itself if we will seek the Lord’s power in our progress and our participation.”

Perfectionism says, “You should have already arrived.” God says, “You are on your way.” Those are very different views.

The most hopeful insight I took away is this: Repenting and rejoicing are much closer than I realized. When I repent and turn toward Christ, I am also turning toward joy. In other words, repentance isn’t a depressing reminder of how far I fall short. It’s a pathway to the happiness and wholeness He wants to give me.

That’s a beautiful way to think about progress. Baby steps still count. Small improvements matter. Even patience in the process is part of the journey. Growth happens gradually, but consistently. He wants me to turn to Him, to use repentance as a tool for transformation, not just correction.

This is possible not because I’m capable enough or disciplined enough, but because the Savior’s grace is enough. That’s the kind of hope I want to carry forward. Not just the hope of being forgiven, but the hope of becoming something new.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 127

For October, I usually promote a General Conference talk that speaks to the perfectionist part of me. This time, I’ve chosen Elder Kearon’s Jesus Christ and Your New Beginning. Here are some of my favorite parts:

I love the thought of new beginnings, unfettered by past mistakes and failures. I love the message of Lamentations 3:22-23 – “It is of the Lord’s mercies that we are not consumed, because his compassions fail not. They are new every morning: great is thy faithfulness.”

Take three minutes and listen to this song by Micah Tyler. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 123

When I read this post by Bethany Faden on Facebook, I could tell immediately that she was onto something. Rather than link to the post, I’m copying it here in its entirety and giving her full credit for it. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 121

After General Conference, for my monthly blog post, I usually choose a talk that deals with some of my perfectionistic tendencies. This time, the obvious choice is Sister Tamara W. Runia, First Counselor in the Young Women General Presidency. Here are some of my favorite quotes from her talk: 

This is one of the concepts that has helped me to become more shame resilient. I distinguish between my infinite worth and my behavior. Although my behavior may be maladaptive at times, my worth in the sight of God never fluctuates. 

You can read the full talk here. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 120

This month, I attended two events designed to help me develop my skills in facilitating psychodrama. 

The first was a weekend retreat sponsored by The Crucible Project. Here’s some more information about the organization as taken from their website:

Focus:
The Crucible Project aims to create a world where people live with integrity, grace, and courage, fulfilling their God-given purpose. 

Method:
They achieve this through transformational retreats, groups, and coaching, fostering communities where people live authentically and with integrity. 

Retreats:
These retreats are designed to challenge individuals to take a hard look at their lives, wrestle with God, and discover new truths about themselves, finding freedom to break away from self-sabotaging beliefs. 

Intense Experience:
The Crucible Weekend is an intense experience that can be emotionally, spiritually, and physically challenging. 

Radical Honesty and Grace:
The retreats emphasize radical honesty and grace, creating a space for individuals to wrestle with God and discover new truths about themselves. 

Community:
The Crucible Project fosters a community of men and women who have gone through the retreats, providing support and encouragement. 

Locations:
The Crucible Project has retreats in the United States, International locations, and Second-level Weekends. 

Vision:
Their vision is a world of men and women who live with integrity, grace, and courage. 

Mission:
Their mission is to ignite personal change in men and women through experiencing Jesus, and taking a journey of radical honesty and self-reflection.  

The retreat I attended was held in Empire, CO, about an hour west of Denver, at the Easter Seals Rocky Mountain Village facility. Most of the meetings were held in a lodge, and we stayed in cabins with other men. There were 37 participants and about that same number of staff members. (In the photo, I’m kneeling in front, second from the left.)

The second event I attended was a one-day Guts Work Facilitation Training held in Taylorsville, UT. It was held at the home of a man who was willing to host it free of charge. Eleven of us were in attendance, men who had previously participated in the Mankind Project NWTA weekend. Three were staff members, and the other eight of us were attendees. 

I’ve had a lot of talk therapy over the years with various counselors, which has been great, and I’ve needed it. However, this approach was different in that it was more experiential, somatic, and physical. It aligns well with a book I recently studied called “The Body Keeps the Score” by Bessel van der Kolk. The central premise of the book is that trauma profoundly impacts the brain and body, leading to physical and emotional dysregulation, and that healing trauma requires understanding and addressing these physiological and neurological changes.

One of the main processes used to heal these wounds is psychodrama. Psychodrama focuses on a person’s real-life experiences and internal conflicts, allowing individuals to explore and express their emotions and experiences through dramatic action. While it can be used in individual therapy, psychodrama is often conducted in a group setting, where participants can act out scenes from their lives under the guidance of a trained facilitator. Put together, then, a psycho-drama is quite literally a “drama of the mind and soul.” 

In each psychodrama process, I was able to re-enact a painful experience from my past. The result of the process is that I’m able to receive closure and resolution. Technically I don’t actually change what happened in the past, but I’m able to change how I feel about what happened. This results in greater peace and freedom. 

Some of my perfectionist tendencies are the result of experiences I had as a kid, where I felt like I needed to be perfect in order to be acceptable. Of course, perfection in this life is impossible, so that created a lot of internal chaos. Working through the scenarios as an adult showed me that those expectations were unrealistic. I can approach myself with kindness and curiosity. I’m better able to give myself grace. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 119

I stumbled across a quote by C.S. Lewis that addresses perfection and how the Lord intends to perfect us. This is great!

C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity (1952; Harper Collins: 2001)

The Lord’s work and glory is to exalt me. And He knows how to do his work.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 117

As I look at setting New Year’s resolutions, which is my MO at this time of year, I typically like to choose a word or phrase as a theme for the coming year. I haven’t settled on this one for sure, but I’m leaning toward “be still.” 

I’m grateful that I’m retired and have a little more time to pull back from the daily grind and find peace and calm. It’s nice to not feel the expectation of constantly needing to “get it right” but rather, breathe in the stillness.