Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 108

I’ve asked myself this question many times. I’ve been hypervigilant for words that could give me hope that God isn’t upset, angered, and displeased with me. So I was grateful to hear this two years ago in April Conference: 

“God does not now see, nor has He ever seen, you as someone to be despised. . . He is not ashamed of you or disappointed in you.” —Elder Patrick Kearon 

I’ve known Kurt Francom through his Leading Saints organization, which I started following about seven years ago. Then I met Kurt five years ago at a retreat (see Part 48). I felt a kinship with him as we talked about how we wished our elders quorums were places where men could be more emotionally vulnerable and supportive. And how it’s common to crave the approval of others. And that it’s hard to see God as pleased with us when we make mistakes. So I could see the beginnings of the book taking root back then. 

As I was studying this book, I often thought: “I wish I’d had this years ago.” I also thought of several people I could send a copy to. It’s probably one of the most important books I’ve come across in the last 5 years. And it has only been available since last month. 

Here’s the summary taken from the back cover of the book:

The full title is Is God Disappointed in Me? Removing Shame from a Gospel of Grace. As a recovering perfectionist, I’ve written about the destructive effects of shame several times on this blog. So one of my favorite parts of the book is Chapter Five: Identity. Usually, Satan doesn’t directly try to get me to do bad things. He attacks my identity as a beloved child of God. My divine nature. My infinite worth. He wants me to focus on my behavior more than my heart. It’s a very subtle approach. Yet, it is so effective. 

I highly recommend this book. 

(There’s an Audible version if you prefer to listen. On Amazon, it’s totally worth the $15.99, but you can get it at your local Costco for $9.99.) 

(Kurt has done several interviews/podcasts about this topic. One of my favorites is this one with Ritchie Steadman, host of The Cultural Hall. It’s about 53 minutes.)

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 107

A few months ago I joined a men’s book discussion group. Every six weeks we choose a book to read and then hold an evening video conference to discuss it. The latest book was “No More Mr. Nice Guy” by Dr. Robert Glover. 

I’d heard this book’s title thrown around a bit, and had even had it recommended to me by two different friends. But I must admit, I was hesitant to read it, mostly because I’ve always thought that being nice was a good thing. So it was providential that I needed to read it for the group discussion. 

After reading the book, I’ll say that I’ve probably been an 80% nice guy for most of my life. Here are some of the traits of the nice guy. Nice guys—

Seek acceptance from others 
Are conflict-avoidant
Are pleasers and givers
Are caretakers
Seek the right way to do things
Try to be perfect and avoid mistakes 
Care a lot about how others perceive them
Have a hard time saying no
Repress their feelings
Want to be different from their fathers
Are more comfortable being with women
Don’t want to rock the boat
Exert tremendous effort to make others happy
Are often co-dependent
Believe they are not OK as they are
Become a chameleon for whoever they are with
Tells people what they want to hear
Link their self-worth to the approval of others
Hide their true intention
Can be perfectionistic
Use indirect ways and manipulation to get what they want
Can be very controlling
Meet other people’s needs at the expense of getting their own needs met
Serve because they think it makes them look good, but might resent it
Are passive-aggressive 
Are afraid if others knew what they were really like, they would be rejected
Withold thoughts and emotions for fear of disapproval from others
Might disagree, but don’t say it, to avoid conflict and arguments
Don’t speak their preferences outright, but beat around the bush
Try to keep the peace 

Most people have some of these traits, but nice guys have most of them.

Luckily the book also includes information on how to move from the nice guy syndrome to becoming the ideal man. The ideal man—

Handles conflict and establishes boundaries.
Holds himself accountable for his own needs and desires.
Addresses and learns from his flaws and mistakes.
Takes charge and genuinely cares for his loved ones.
Communicates and shares his thoughts and emotions openly and honestly.
Builds healthy and meaningful relationships with everyone, including both women and men.

For so long, I was in self-deception about the destructive impacts of being a nice guy. At this point, I am healing from the unhealthy characteristics and increasing in the healthy characteristics. I’m grateful for this book and how it has enlightened my awareness. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 106

For this month’s post, I will quote directly from my friend, Jason. It resonates with the perfectionist part of me. 

We men like formulas. We like bullet points. We like bright lines. They make life easier. They cut through mystery and doubt. We’d love it if such things could govern our relationships with God. They would make following him easier, too. At least, we think they would. So we try to create them. It starts innocently: Someone seeks God and finds him—through a specific prayer or practice, or through a particular way of studying Scripture or being in community or doing service. But, then, that person decides that’s “the” way to find God. Others are persuaded, of course, because they want to find God too. And a formula is born, a bullet point, a bright line, a rule about how our relationships with God must look.

The thing is, while God never changes (James 1:17, Hebrews 13:8), our relationships with him do. They’re ever-changing, ever challenging (2 Corinthians 3:18). There’s always more with God. There’s always mystery. And there’s always something new. But because we fear change and fear being challenged, we often cling to what’s worked in the past or what’s worked for someone else. We create a rule, repeat a ritual, but we may not grow and mature in our relationships with God.

Okay, so what do we do?

“Don’t set people up as experts over your life, letting them tell you what to do. Save that authority for God; let him tell you what to do” (Matthew 23:8-10 MSG).

Set aside some time to pray and to listen. Ask the Holy Spirit to guide you. Ask where you might find him next—maybe in Scripture; maybe through serving; or on a short-term mission; or out in his creation; or something else. Let him guide your thoughts. Let him keep you on track.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 105

Part of the challenge of mortality is the unpredictability. Perfectionists like things to happen in order and on schedule. I recently heard an analogy that I like:

Life is like a puzzle, only I don’t get to see the final picture at the beginning. 

So I start out by finding a few pieces that fit together, usually around the outer edge. The outside edges are easier. (Similarly, I might be able to fix my outside so it looks put together. But on the inside, it’s more difficult and messy.)  

I might see a piece that looks like it would fit, but when I try it, it’s not quite right, so I have to set it aside for the time being. I don’t throw out the whole puzzle just because I can’t figure out where that particular piece goes. 

I might have a piece that is oddly shaped, or that is particularly distinctive. When I see where it matches, it’s pretty obvious.

There are times when I need to pull away from putting the puzzle together to focus on other concerns, and it seems like not much gets done for a period of time. When I come back to it later, I might have a fresh outlook that helps. 

Other people might stop by and help me put some of the pieces together. They might see connections I’ve not seen. 

Sometimes I need to let go of the picture I’m trying to create. My idea of what it “should” look like can blind me to what it “could” look like. When I’m determined to create a particular outcome, I can close myself off to possibilities hiding in the pile of options right in front of me. 

As I gradually piece the puzzle together, the big picture starts to emerge. 

At Christmas time, we typically take neighbor gifts around to the people on our street. It’s fun to come up with a clever saying to go with the gift:
• Just popping in to say Merry Christmas! (popcorn)
• Merry Swiss Miss! (hot chocolate)
• We whisk you a Merry Christmas! (wire whisk)
• Seasoned Greetings! (bottle of seasoning)
• We’re soda lighted to wish you Happy Holidays! (bottle of soda)

You get the idea. 

So this year we gave each neighbor a small wooden puzzle with the tag: Piece on Earth! 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 104

This month I’m going to pull content straight from a short article on the Church’s website.

You’re not perfect yet, and that’s OK!
Do you struggle with getting down on yourself, especially when you mess up?

Some guilt is spiritually healthy. For example, if we sin and feel bad about it, we may want to repent and do better next time. That’s a positive process.

On the other hand, we can be paralyzed by a fear of making a mistake. This attitude of perfectionism can be poisonous to our progression. Put simply, perfectionism means you want to be better without ever messing up or expressing strong emotions like anger, sadness, anxiety, and fear. Instead of learning from our mistakes and moving on, we spend a lot of energy dwelling on past mistakes or avoiding growing experiences altogether.

Sound familiar? If so, here are some things to think about:

Emotions are strengths, not weaknesses.
We can focus on improvement, not perfection.
God understands that we may sometimes make mistakes. And learning from the mistakes we make is part of His plan for our progression.
The Atonement of Jesus Christ covers our weaknesses and shortcomings as well as our sins.

Our prophet, President Russell M. Nelson, taught that our perfection is pending. True perfection will not be achieved in this mortal life, but in the next life, after we are resurrected, through the grace of Jesus Christ.

Watch this video about a young woman’s journey in overcoming perfectionism.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 103

The more I learn about perfection, the more I come to realize that I can’t perfect myself. I can only be perfected in Christ. Although I can’t perfect myself, I can make choices that will keep me on a path to greater light and truth. And with greater light and truth, I can see things more clearly. This aligns with a statement by Joseph Smith which I call the “nearer and clearer” promise: 

“The nearer man approaches perfection, the clearer are his views, and the greater his enjoyments, till he has overcome the evils of his life and lost every desire for sin; and like the ancients, arrives at the point in faith where he is wrapped in the power and glory of his Maker and is caught up to dwell with him. But we consider that this is a station to which no man ever arrived in a moment” (Joseph Smith, History of the Church, 2:8).

This is actually happening to me—on a small scale. When I invite the Savior into me, He changes my heart, little by little, and I take on His attributes a little more. As a result, I have eyes to see things and ears to hear things more readily. Things that may have been hidden from my younger self. 

This has all been a gift, nothing I have earned or deserved, really. 

As I reflect, I can think of a few things that have contributed to this change of heart. 

I think part of it has been the fact that I’m spending more time in the temple. President Nelson promised blessings from increased time in the temple, and I’m realizing that. 

“It is significant that the Savior chose to appear to the people at the temple. It is His house. It is filled with His power. Let us never lose sight of what the Lord is doing for us now. He is making His temples more accessible. He is accelerating the pace at which we are building temples. He is increasing our ability to help gather Israel. He is also making it easier for each of us to become spiritually refined. I promise that increased time in the temple will bless your life in ways nothing else can… My dear brothers and sisters, may you focus on the temple in ways you never have before. I bless you to grow closer to God and Jesus Christ every day” (Russell M. Nelson, CR, November 2022).

Another reason I’m experiencing this is because I’m now retired and have more time to spend serving others. And when we give, we receive back manifold. The Lord is giving me more opportunities to minister and be ministered to. And I’m in a good position to respond to those opportunities. 

“There are doors we can open, blessings we can give, hearts we can heal, burdens we can lift, testimonies we can strengthen, lives we can save, and joy we can bring” (Russell M. Nelson, CR, April 2018).

I give thanks to the Lord for His grace, which has allowed me to see things more clearly. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 102

The prophet has encouraged us to spend time with the Lord and learn to “Hear Him.” For much of my life, I’ve wondered about how to really do that. How to feel His spirit and know that’s what I’m feeling. It has been described as a “burning in the bosom” or a “still, small voice.” Some experience chills, others a feeling of warmth or comfort. I’ve actually had all of these, to some extent, but not as profoundly as it sounds like others have. 

My perfectionistic inclinations would have me limit the ways in which the Lord can speak to me. But I’m becoming more convinced that everyone is so unique. The way we experience life is unique. Two people can experience the same event and come away with significantly different perspectives. 

So why wouldn’t the Lord speak to me in ways specific to me? He does! 

I get quiet promptings, thoughts, and impressions throughout any given day. These would come under the “still, small voice” category. But when I really want to hear Him, I get mindful. I find that when I can move from the analytical part of me to the creative part of me, I can commune with Him relatively easily. Just in the past few weeks, I’ve had times where He has answered some questions and calmed some fears I’ve had for a long time. In fact, one experience was quite miraculous. All it took was for me to “be still” and exercise faith in Him to a higher degree. 

President David O. McKay was a proponent of mindfulness, which he called meditation

“I think we pay too little attention to the value of meditation, a principle of devotion. Meditation is the language of the soul. It is defined as ‘a form of private devotion or spiritual exercise, consisting in deep, continued reflection on some religious theme.’ Meditation is a form of prayer.

“Meditation is one of the most secret, most sacred doors through which we pass into the presence of the Lord” (Teachings of Presidents of the Church: David O. McKay). 

As a proponent of mindful living, it makes sense that the Lord would speak to me through this method. Nephi tells us “For the Lord God giveth light unto the understanding; for he speaketh unto men according to their language, unto their understanding (2 Nephi 31:3).” Since mindfulness is part of my language, the Lord individualizes his voice to me in this way. I’ve come to see Him as a very personal, compassionate, merciful Being.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 101

(This is a continuation of the previous post.) 

There are two ways to look at a Deliverer.

One is that he delivers us from something. Like bondage or errors. 

The other is that he delivers something to us. Like the mail carrier does, or the pizza delivery guy, or like a woman delivering a baby.  

Jesus puts in our path resources to help us move forward in our progression. He delivers to us opportunities for growth. These might come in the form of:

A podcast, a friend, a conference talk, a therapist, a meme or YouTube video, a challenge, a paradigm shift, a class or course, medication, technology, a mentor, a support group, a new beginning, and the list goes on. 

Because Jesus is a Comforter, he delivers to us comfort. 

He delivers peace, because he is the Prince of Peace. 

He delivers to us truth and light. 

He delivers strength and resilience. 

He delivers healing and hope. 

He delivers ordinances and covenants. 

As the Good Shepherd, he delivers us to pastures green and sweet.

He prepares a supper and invites us to partake freely.

At His glorious Second Coming, He will deliver us to the next level of existence.

I have a strong testimony of the enabling power of The Savior’s atonement. There are so many things he helps me to accomplish, which I couldn’t in and of my own self. He truly is the source of every good thing. He is the vine and I am the branch. In the same way that the roots and trunk of a tree provide nourishment and sustenance to the branches, Jesus Christ is the living water and the bread of life that gives me growth, strength, and fruits. I am perfected in Him.

To be continued . . . with Part 102.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 100

Jesus has many names, titles, and roles: Messiah, Good Shepherd, Master, Alpha & Omega, The Vine, The Anointed One, Savior, King, Redeemer, etc.

For the past few weeks, I’ve been thinking about Jesus Christ as Deliverer and Rescuer. Jesus is the Deliverer of mankind because He rescues all from the bondage of death and the repentant from the penalties of sin.

The word “deliverer,” in Hebrew, means “to cause to escape; to carry away safely.” The Savior “causes us to escape and carries us away safely,” delivering us from the evil one.

The scriptures are full of examples of how the Lord has delivered his children:

He delivered Abraham from the pagan priests.

He delivered Isaac from Abraham with a ram. 

As a type of Christ, Moses delivered the children of Israel from Egypt.

The Passover, signified the delivery of the firstborn sons of the Israelites. 

Moses raised up a brazen serpent in the wilderness, which, if the people looked on they were healed.

Daniel in the lion’s den was delivered from the lions.

Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego were delivered from the fiery furnace. 

Esther and the Jews were delivered from Haman’s decree.

Naomi and Ruth were delivered by Boaz, a type of Christ. 

The Lord delivered Jonah from the belly of the whale.

The Lord delivered Noah and his family from the great flood. 

Joseph was delivered from Potiphar and from prison to become second in command to Pharoah.

David was delivered from Goliath because of his trust in the Lord. 

Peter was rescued from sinking into the water.

The Lord delivered Peter and John from prison. Also Paul.

In performing his many miracles, Jesus delivered people from the effects of mortality: diseases, demonic possession, the blind, the deaf, the lame. 

The Lord delivered the family of Lehi from the destruction of Jerusalem.

He delivered Nephi from his older brothers. 

Alma and Amulek from prison.

The Nephites when they fought in the strength of the Lord.

The believers from those who sought their lives. 

And when he visited the Nephites at the temple in Bountiful, he again performed many miracles, delivering them from their afflictions and infirmities. 

In the latter days, the Lord delivered Joseph Smith by preserving his life so he could begin ushering in the restoration of the Gospel. 

He delivered the saints by guiding them across the plains to the Salt Lake Valley. 

But sometimes, the Lord doesn’t promise deliverance. 

Paul had a thorn in the flesh, and he prayed multiple times for it to be removed, but it wasn’t. 

Abinadi was burned and not rescued.

Many Anti-nephi-lehies were killed at the hands of the Amulonites and Amalakites. 

The original 12 apostles of Christ each were martyred for what they believed. 

Some of the pioneers in the handcart companies didn’t make it to the valley. 

Christ may not always give physical deliverance, but He offers deliverance from physical and spiritual death, through the power of His atonement. 

In today’s world, we are also looking for a deliverer. We are looking for a superhero to rescue us from disasters & villains. Why do you think the DC and Marvel movies are so popular?

Christ still delivers us today. Not so much from villains and disasters. But . . . 

From our natural man tendencies.

From addictions.

From the pain of past mistakes, bad choices.

From the hands of the adversary.

From the bondage of sin. 

He delivers us from the consequences of false information that can come to us from other people. 

As a hen gathers her chickens under her wings, Christ delivers us from those who would destroy us. 

He delivers me from my perfectionistic tendencies. 

 To be continued . . . with Part 101.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 99

The Reunion and Self-care

Part of my perfectionism is the desire to avoid rejection. If I don’t perform at a certain level of excellence it won’t be acceptable to others. Another part is the desire to fit in. I need to meet the expectations of others, in order to belong. 

This past weekend I attended a family reunion at Grandpa’s Farm in Southern Utah. My mother’s side of the family holds an extended reunion on the last weekend in June on the odd years. My maternal grandfather, Arthur Delano Cox had a farm just west of Rockville and across the river from Grafton. He passed it on to his oldest son Alma Cox, who ran the farm until he became too old. Then he passed it on to his oldest son, Tracy Cox. Tracy has maintained the farm and made it available to the family for reunions. 


Typically, we’ve had assignments as part of the reunion activities, and the responsibilities (meals, games, hikes, swimming, program, etc.) would rotate through the 1st generation cousins. And, because of my perfectionism, I’ve usually felt a lot of pressure to get things exactly right, whatever my responsibility was. And it took precedence over developing connections with my relatives. This is the Martha vs. Mary issue. And I’ve tended to be a Martha in the past.

But many of the responsibilities have now been passed down to the next generation. So I was able to mostly just relax, and spend time with family. It was different and wonderful. 


Many of the attendees camp at the farm for a few days. So there are a lot of tents, RVs, trailers, etc. But this time I reserved a hotel in LaVerkin (about 17 minutes from the farm). I was able to sleep in a comfortable bed and get a shower each morning. This meant getting good sleep and helping me have a better start to the day. I also picked up some healthy food and put it in a cooler, so I wouldn’t be at the mercy of whatever was being served. 

So this year, I did more to promote my own self-care. And it felt really good. When I’m healthier mentally and emotionally, I bring a healthier version of myself to others. 

To be continued . . . with Part 100.