Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 115

When I watch General Conference, I listen for specific guidance for those of us who struggle to feel God’s love. Elder Hirst’s talk stood out to me. Let me share some of my favorite parts. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 114

It was 10 years ago this month that I seriously decided to meet with a counselor. 

The world in which I grew up held a stigma toward counseling. If I weren’t able to deal with whatever life dealt me, then I was weak and incapable. Only really messed-up people needed to see a shrink. 

But I finally decided that I needed help with my perfectionistic thinking. So, since then, I’ve come to be a proponent of receiving counseling. Maybe not everyone needs it, but many could benefit from help from a qualified support person. In addition to professional counselors, this could include life coaches, social workers, mentors, sponsors, and even just a trusted friend lending a listening ear. 

I had my “main” counselor for almost 8 years. We typically met for an hour per week. Fortunately, my insurance paid for most of the cost and my copay was minimal. When I retired, I needed to find a new one, since he didn’t take my retiree insurance. I’ve been through three more, to find another one who was the right fit for me. I need to feel like the counselor has the expertise to help me, there needs to be a rapport between us, and I need to feel that he/she genuinely cares about me. 

Here are some of the ways in which counseling has benefited me. 

My counselor has helped me with perfectionism in really supportive and practical ways. First, he created a safe space where I felt comfortable opening up about my struggles. Perfectionism can be exhausting, and I sometimes feel like I have to constantly be on-task or that I’m not good enough, so it’s important that a counselor listens without judgment.

He has helped me recognize the underlying beliefs driving my perfectionism. A lot of times, perfectionists feel like their worth is tied to how well they perform, or they’re afraid of failure because it feels like a personal reflection of who they are. My counselor worked with me to challenge these beliefs and start breaking down the idea that I need to be perfect to be valuable.

Another thing my counselor has done is encourage me to set more realistic goals and expectations for myself. Instead of aiming for “perfect,” he has helped me aim for “good enough” in different areas of my life. He’d talk through what those more balanced goals might look like and how to be okay with things not going perfectly all the time.

My counselor also taught me coping skills for dealing with the stress that comes up when things don’t go as planned. For example, he showed me how to practice self-compassion—talking to myself kindly rather than beating myself up for every little mistake. He also helped me learn how to step back and take breaks, rather than pushing myself to the point of burnout.

He has helped me uncover where these perfectionist tendencies started—some in childhood, some from pressure at school and work—and then we worked on healing from that. The goal wasn’t for me to stop caring about doing things well, but to help me feel more balanced, more at peace with myself, and less driven by fear and unrealistic expectations.

I’ve appreciated that my counselor has walked alongside me as I’ve learned to let go of the need for perfection and embrace being human, with all the imperfections that come with it.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 113

I recently took a test to see whether I have a secure or insecure attachment style. It turns out that I have an insecure attachment style. 

Attachment theory, originally developed by John Bowlby and expanded by Mary Ainsworth, suggests that early relationships with caregivers shape how individuals perceive themselves and interact with others throughout life. 

Here’s how insecure attachment styles—specifically anxious and avoidant attachments—can lead to perfectionism:

Anxious attachment, also known as preoccupied attachment, is characterized by a strong fear of abandonment and an excessive need for approval and reassurance. Individuals with this attachment style often feel insecure about their worth and fear rejection. This insecurity can lead to perfectionism.

• Desire for Approval: Individuals with anxious attachment often believe they must be perfect to be loved or accepted. They may strive to meet excessively high standards, hoping to gain approval, validation, and avoid rejection. Their self-worth becomes tied to external validation, making them prone to perfectionist behaviors.

• Fear of Abandonment: The constant fear of being abandoned can drive individuals to avoid mistakes at all costs. They may think that any error could lead to being judged or rejected, so they strive for flawlessness in their actions, thoughts, and appearance.

• Over-Responsibility: Anxiously attached individuals might feel overly responsible for the happiness of others. They might engage in perfectionist behavior to try and control outcomes, believing that if they do everything perfectly, they can prevent negative outcomes and maintain relationships.

Avoidant attachment, or dismissive-avoidant attachment, is marked by a tendency to downplay the importance of relationships, maintain emotional distance, and rely heavily on self-sufficiency. Despite their appearance of independence, avoidant individuals also experience insecurity, which can manifest in perfectionism.

• Need for Control: Avoidant individuals often strive to maintain control over their environment and emotions to prevent vulnerability. Perfectionism can be a coping mechanism to control outcomes and avoid feeling dependent on others or exposed emotionally.

• Fear of Criticism and Judgment: Avoidant individuals may fear being criticized or judged because it threatens their self-image of competence and independence. They may strive for perfection to avoid situations where their flaws could be exposed, which could make them feel vulnerable or inadequate.

• Emotional Distancing: By focusing on perfection in work, hobbies, or personal appearance, avoidant individuals can distract themselves from emotional discomfort or intimacy issues. Perfectionism can become a way to keep others at a distance, avoiding the need for deep emotional connections that might be uncomfortable.

Insecure attachment styles create a fundamental sense of uncertainty about one’s worth and relationships. This insecurity can lead to perfectionism as a way to cope.

• Coping with Low Self-Esteem: Insecure attachment often results in low self-esteem. Individuals may turn to perfectionism, believing that if they can achieve perfect standards, they will finally feel good about themselves and be worthy of love and respect.

• Managing Anxiety: Both anxious and avoidant attached individuals may experience high levels of anxiety about relationships and self-worth. Perfectionism can serve as a way to manage this anxiety by providing a sense of control and predictability.

• Avoiding Emotional Pain: By focusing on perfection, individuals can distract themselves from underlying emotional pain and the fear of inadequacy. It becomes a way to avoid facing deeper issues related to their attachment style.

An insecure attachment style can lead me to seek security and validation in maladaptive ways. Perfectionism can become a strategy to cope with the fears, insecurities, and unmet needs stemming from these early attachment experiences. While striving for excellence and improvement is healthy, when driven by deep-seated insecurities, it can lead to chronic stress, burnout, and dissatisfaction. Understanding the roots of perfectionism in attachment can help me develop healthier ways to seek fulfillment, connection, and self-acceptance.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 112

As a teenager attending Dixie High School in St. George, UT, I played trombone in the marching band. A few times each year, we would march in parades that started going east on Main Street and later turned and came back west on Tabernacle Street. Our band director was a stickler for dressing appropriately. We wore the band uniforms and each of us had to buy our own white sneakers. 

One time when we were marching in a homecoming parade, trombones leading the band, I looked down and saw that the shoelace on my right shoe had come untied. The shoe was becoming looser on my foot. I knew that at some point I would need to stop, step out of line, and tie the shoelace. Otherwise, I would lose the shoe. 

As we marched along, I began thinking about when and where might be a good place to step out. I watched for places where fewer spectators were along the route. I also wanted to choose a time when we were not playing a tune or doing a formation or maneuver. 

It took my attention away from doing my job as a member of the marching band. It was difficult to concentrate on marching and also plan where to stop. 

Since then, I have used this dilemma as a metaphor. When I have something important that needs to be done, yet there hasn’t been a convenient time to do it, it’s always there at the back of my mind. “It feels like my shoelace is untied.” 

For a perfectionist, this creates angst. I have a checklist mentality and not being able to check everything off feels unsettling. It also messes with my ability to distinguish between what is urgent and what is important. 

In a 1954 speech, President Dwight D. Eisenhower said, “I have two kinds of problems, the urgent and the important. The urgent are not important, and the important are never urgent.” 

The Eisenhower Matrix, also known as the Urgent-Important Matrix, is a time management and decision-making method to help effectively prioritize tasks. The framework categorizes your tasks into four quadrants based on their urgency and importance:

I. Important and urgent
Tasks that have high importance and need immediate attention.
• Answer urgent emails
• Medical emergencies
• Projects with deadlines
• Crises and catastrophes
                       
II. Important, but not urgent
Tasks that don’t have a deadline but move you closer to your goals.
• Long-term planning
• Personal improvement
• Relationship building
• Values clarification
                       
III. Not important, but urgent
Tasks that need to get done but don’t need your expertise. 
• Busy work
• Meal prep
• Interruptions
• Plan staff picnic
                       
IV. Not important and not urgent
Tasks that don’t add value and can distract you from your goals. 
• Binge on social media
• Video games
• Infuriating political news
• Sort your junk mail

Stephen R. Covey, popularized the Eisenhower Matrix, showing how it can help in achieving personal and professional effectiveness. He stressed that the key to time management isn’t about doing more, but rather deciding where your time is best spent.

How might a perfectionist struggle with approaching tasks in these four quadrants? 

Quadrant I: Perfectionists may struggle with tasks in this quadrant because the urgency can increase their fear of making mistakes. They might spend a lot of time perfecting details, which can lead to stress and burnout.

Quadrant II: Perfectionists may procrastinate on starting these tasks due to the desire to perform them flawlessly.

Quadrant III: Perfectionists may find it difficult to delegate or ignore tasks in this quadrant, even though they do not contribute significantly to long-term goals. They might feel compelled to handle these tasks personally to ensure they are done correctly.

Quadrant IV: Perfectionists might get caught up in these tasks as a form of procrastination or because they feel guilty about leaving any task undone.

By becoming aware of these potential pitfalls, I can hopefully avoid them and put my efforts toward becoming more effective. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 111

The older I get, the more I realize that there is a lot of information out there that is good and true. (Yes, there is also a lot that is bad and false, but stay with me here.) I used to think that if a concept wasn’t spoken over the pulpit at General Conference, then we couldn’t accept it as true. That was absolute thinking. I hope I have a healthier approach now. 

President Nelson taught:

Joseph Smith taught:

Brigham Young taught:

I am encouraged to learn by study and also by faith. I can embrace truth, wherever I find it. May I have the spirit of discernment to distinguish between truth and error. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 110

Perfectionists are often inclined to expect unreasonable things from ourselves. When I get inspiration, it’s not enough to experience a still small voice; I want clanging bells and flashing lights, thunder and lightning. Otherwise, I’m inadequate. Elder Dushku addressed this issue in his General Conference talk last month: 

So then, it’s unrealistic to expect singular Alma-like or Saul-like visions or visitations. Rather, ray upon ray, inspiration will come to enlighten me throughout my journey. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 109

During General Conference, I listen to see who addresses anything pertaining to perfectionism. This time, I chose Elder Kearon’s talk because of the hope it gives for removing barriers to returning to God. It also shows how much God wants us back with Him. I pulled several paragraphs straight from his address: 

How could he be more direct? How could I dispute the Lord’s goodness and love? And Elder Kearon’s fun British accent adds to the sweetness of the truths he shares.

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 108

I’ve asked myself this question many times. I’ve been hypervigilant for words that could give me hope that God isn’t upset, angered, and displeased with me. So I was grateful to hear this two years ago in April Conference: 

“God does not now see, nor has He ever seen, you as someone to be despised. . . He is not ashamed of you or disappointed in you.” —Elder Patrick Kearon 

I’ve known Kurt Francom through his Leading Saints organization, which I started following about seven years ago. Then I met Kurt five years ago at a retreat (see Part 48). I felt a kinship with him as we talked about how we wished our elders quorums were places where men could be more emotionally vulnerable and supportive. And how it’s common to crave the approval of others. And that it’s hard to see God as pleased with us when we make mistakes. So I could see the beginnings of the book taking root back then. 

As I was studying this book, I often thought: “I wish I’d had this years ago.” I also thought of several people I could send a copy to. It’s probably one of the most important books I’ve come across in the last 5 years. And it has only been available since last month. 

Here’s the summary taken from the back cover of the book:

The full title is Is God Disappointed in Me? Removing Shame from a Gospel of Grace. As a recovering perfectionist, I’ve written about the destructive effects of shame several times on this blog. So one of my favorite parts of the book is Chapter Five: Identity. Usually, Satan doesn’t directly try to get me to do bad things. He attacks my identity as a beloved child of God. My divine nature. My infinite worth. He wants me to focus on my behavior more than my heart. It’s a very subtle approach. Yet, it is so effective. 

I highly recommend this book. 

(There’s an Audible version if you prefer to listen. On Amazon, it’s totally worth the $15.99, but you can get it at your local Costco for $9.99.) 

(Kurt has done several interviews/podcasts about this topic. One of my favorites is this one with Ritchie Steadman, host of The Cultural Hall. It’s about 53 minutes.)

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 107

A few months ago I joined a men’s book discussion group. Every six weeks we choose a book to read and then hold an evening video conference to discuss it. The latest book was “No More Mr. Nice Guy” by Dr. Robert Glover. 

I’d heard this book’s title thrown around a bit, and had even had it recommended to me by two different friends. But I must admit, I was hesitant to read it, mostly because I’ve always thought that being nice was a good thing. So it was providential that I needed to read it for the group discussion. 

After reading the book, I’ll say that I’ve probably been an 80% nice guy for most of my life. Here are some of the traits of the nice guy. Nice guys—

Seek acceptance from others 
Are conflict-avoidant
Are pleasers and givers
Are caretakers
Seek the right way to do things
Try to be perfect and avoid mistakes 
Care a lot about how others perceive them
Have a hard time saying no
Repress their feelings
Want to be different from their fathers
Are more comfortable being with women
Don’t want to rock the boat
Exert tremendous effort to make others happy
Are often co-dependent
Believe they are not OK as they are
Become a chameleon for whoever they are with
Tells people what they want to hear
Link their self-worth to the approval of others
Hide their true intention
Can be perfectionistic
Use indirect ways and manipulation to get what they want
Can be very controlling
Meet other people’s needs at the expense of getting their own needs met
Serve because they think it makes them look good, but might resent it
Are passive-aggressive 
Are afraid if others knew what they were really like, they would be rejected
Withold thoughts and emotions for fear of disapproval from others
Might disagree, but don’t say it, to avoid conflict and arguments
Don’t speak their preferences outright, but beat around the bush
Try to keep the peace 

Most people have some of these traits, but nice guys have most of them.

Luckily the book also includes information on how to move from the nice guy syndrome to becoming the ideal man. The ideal man—

Handles conflict and establishes boundaries.
Holds himself accountable for his own needs and desires.
Addresses and learns from his flaws and mistakes.
Takes charge and genuinely cares for his loved ones.
Communicates and shares his thoughts and emotions openly and honestly.
Builds healthy and meaningful relationships with everyone, including both women and men.

For so long, I was in self-deception about the destructive impacts of being a nice guy. At this point, I am healing from the unhealthy characteristics and increasing in the healthy characteristics. I’m grateful for this book and how it has enlightened my awareness. 

Confessions of a Recovering Perfectionist – Part 106

For this month’s post, I will quote directly from my friend, Jason. It resonates with the perfectionist part of me. 

We men like formulas. We like bullet points. We like bright lines. They make life easier. They cut through mystery and doubt. We’d love it if such things could govern our relationships with God. They would make following him easier, too. At least, we think they would. So we try to create them. It starts innocently: Someone seeks God and finds him—through a specific prayer or practice, or through a particular way of studying Scripture or being in community or doing service. But, then, that person decides that’s “the” way to find God. Others are persuaded, of course, because they want to find God too. And a formula is born, a bullet point, a bright line, a rule about how our relationships with God must look.

The thing is, while God never changes (James 1:17, Hebrews 13:8), our relationships with him do. They’re ever-changing, ever challenging (2 Corinthians 3:18). There’s always more with God. There’s always mystery. And there’s always something new. But because we fear change and fear being challenged, we often cling to what’s worked in the past or what’s worked for someone else. We create a rule, repeat a ritual, but we may not grow and mature in our relationships with God.

Okay, so what do we do?

“Don’t set people up as experts over your life, letting them tell you what to do. Save that authority for God; let him tell you what to do” (Matthew 23:8-10 MSG).

Set aside some time to pray and to listen. Ask the Holy Spirit to guide you. Ask where you might find him next—maybe in Scripture; maybe through serving; or on a short-term mission; or out in his creation; or something else. Let him guide your thoughts. Let him keep you on track.